Challenging Bluebeard: ‘Bluebeard’s Egg’ (1983), The Piano (1993) and Barbe Bleue (2009)

Abstract

In this essay, I analyse contemporary feminist retellings of the Bluebeard tale. I concentrate in particular on three revisions: Margaret Atwood’s short story, ‘Bluebeard’s Egg’ (1983); Jane Campion’s film, The Piano (1993); and Catherine Breillat’s film, Barbe Bleue (2009). I compare these works on the basis of their challenging nature in respect to traditional perceptions of women and femininity pursued by modern understandings of the folk story. I thus argue that Atwood’s, Campion’s, and Breillat’s variations on the Bluebeard theme complicate the view of women as passive objects of agency, and also the belief that curiosity is a vicious feminine feature that leads to disobedience that has to be punished by death. I focus on the outstanding features of the Bluebeard story: the characters of Bluebeard and his wife; the role of the secret chamber; and the meaning of the key. Showing how the three authors transform the old tale through the narrative approaches of mirroring and doubling, I explain how they reach a complex, often problematic, representation of their female protagonists.

Keywords

Jane Campion, Margareth Atwood, Catherine Breillat, feminist retellings, fairy tales, film studies, literature, Bluebeard

How to Cite

Giuliana, E., (2014) “Challenging Bluebeard: ‘Bluebeard’s Egg’ (1983), The Piano (1993) and Barbe Bleue (2009)”, Opticon1826 16, Art. 7.

50

Views

28

Downloads

Share

Authors

Elisa Giuliana

Download

Issue

Publication details

Dates

Licence

All rights reserved

Peer Review

This article has been peer reviewed.

File Checksums (MD5)

  • XML: 20db8c97b77574de57cd4ed4b4daad1b
  • PDF: 20db8c97b77574de57cd4ed4b4daad1b