ojs2 has produced an error Message: WARNING: fopen(/var/www/html/cache/fc-journalSettings-19.php): failed to open stream: Permission denied In file: /var/www/html/lib/pkp/classes/cache/FileCache.inc.php At line: 86 Stacktrace: Server info: OS: Linux PHP Version: 5.6.40 Apache Version: Apache/2.4.43 (Unix) DB Driver: mysql DB server version: 10.2.31-MariaDB-1:10.2.31+maria~bionic
#284 Summary

#284 Summary


Authors Journal Editor Mail
Title Introduction to Aesthetic Unity
Original file 284-286-1-SM.docx  2014-02-07
Supp. files None    Add a Supplementary File
Submitter Journal Editor Mail
Date submitted 2014-02-07
Section Aesthetic Unity
Change to
Abstract Views 1556


    Review Editing Request Action
Editor Journal Editor Mail       2014-02-07 Delete
   Add Section EditorAdd EditorAdd Self


Status Published    Vol 1, No 1 (2013): Unity/Disunity: Selected Contributions Reject and Archive Submission
Initiated 2014-02-07
Last modified 2014-03-06

Submission Metadata

Edit Metadata


Name Journal Editor Mail
URL http://www.grad.ucl.ac.uk/societies/society-for-comparative-cultural-inquiry.html
Affiliation UCL
Country United Kingdom
Bio Statement Tropos is a for researchers and scholars working in any area of comparative cultural inquiry. Its aim is to foster and promote innovative critical thought and comparative research in the areas of literature, art, film, history, philosophy, politics, critical theory, and all related subjects. Graduate students working in these areas are invited to send in proposals for papers on an ad hoc basis, although there are two formal publications each year.
Principal contact for editorial correspondence.

Title and Abstract

Title Introduction to Aesthetic Unity

Aesthetic Unity


Ever since Aristotle wrote his Poetics, aesthetic theory has concerned itself with various unities. In drama there are the Aristotelian unities of time and place, in literature the question of unity of form and content always looms on the horizon, whereas in the more recently developed field of translation studies the unityof meaning between translation and original is an ever-thorny issue. At the same time, since the appearance of modern subjectivity we have witnessed attempts to tear apart such unities – whether in the name of a sublime perception (as in Romantic aesthetics), challenging the patriarchal tradition (in many feminist approaches) or through the deconstruction of a Eurocentric canon from a post-colonial or post-modern perspective.

The papers in this section offer two very different challenges to the unity of a text. Juan Cruz turns to one of the most monolithic – and at the same time, least unified – texts of the Western tradition: the Bible. Cruz demonstrates that the contradictions in the use of metaphors in the Book of Micah are symptomatic of an ideological rift at the very heart of the book’s message about Israel. In Jimmy Packham’s paper a comparable conflict between unity and disunity are presented within the work of one single author: Edgar Allan Poe. While Poe advocates a ‘unity of impression’ in literary composition, Packham shows how the author’s scientific belief that ‘true unity negates physical matter’ counterbalances his search for aesthetic unity and leaves an irresolvable contradiction at the core of his texts. Together, these papers reveal how specific elements of a text can disrupt and destroy the greater unity that those texts aspire to.


Academic discipline and sub-disciplines
Geo-spatial coverage
Chronological or historical coverage
Research sample characteristics
Type, method or approach
Language en

Supporting Agencies


Copyright © 2018 UCL | Disclaimer | Freedom of Information | Privacy and Cookies